Hearing Loss and Dementia

A recent JAMA study, found here describes a strong correlation between hearing loss and dementia in older adults. A commentator interpreted this correlation to mean that people should do all they can to mitigate hearing loss as soon as it appears so as to reduce the risk of developing dementia. You may want to use this study, and particularly the commentator’s assertion as an example of how easy it is to over-interpret the meaning of a correlation.

Everyday Examples of Descriptive Norms in Action

Descriptive norms can be seen operating when street performers, cocktail lounge pianists, coat-check attendants, baristas, and others who work for tips “seed” their tip containers with bills in the amounts they hope their customers will contribute. The idea is that if a pianist’s tip jar already holds a few five-dollar bills, and maybe even a ten, listeners are led to assume that these are normal tip amounts and might thus be more likely to contribute similar amounts themselves.

Obedience to Pranksters Posing as Authorities

The human tendency to obey the orders of legitimate authority figures has been exploited by pranksters who have influenced unsuspecting people to engage in outrageous and potentially dangerous or harmful behavior. For example, in April 2016, employees of California and Oklahoma fast-food restaurants broke out all their stores’ windows after callers claiming to be fire department officials ordered them to ventilate supposedly deadly levels of carbon monoxide. Orders from a caller posing as a Boston police detective led four restaurant managers there to strip-search their employees for evidence of criminal activity. In other cases, residents of a special needs school were given unnecessary electric shock treatments on the telephoned orders of a hoaxer, and hospital nurses obeyed medical treatment orders given by a teenager who claimed to be a doctor. A summary of such cases, and the details of one in 2004 that led to a criminal trial for the caller are available in this news story. A much more elaborate description of this hoax, its perpetrator, and its horrific impact on some of its targets is presented in a three-episode series on Netflix.

Nightmares and Dementia

An article found here describes a study of middle-aged and older adults showing that men who have nightmares at least once a week are significantly more likely than other men to develop dementia. This correlation did not reach statistical significance for women. Speculating on the basis for this association, the researchers suggest that when dementia is in its undetectable early stages, it creates negative emotions that may be expressed as depression while awake and as nightmares while asleep. They hypothesize that medication that can reduce nightmares might also help to slow cognitive decline. Is the association between nightmares and development of dementia causal or correlational? If the latter, what third factor(s) might be responsible for it and why did it only appear in men? The study on which this article is based provides a good example of research methods whose interpretation depends on critical thinking about correlation and causation. It should provide a useful target for classroom discussion as well as a topic for student writing assignments aimed at promoting critical thinking.

Cultural Influences on Defining Psychological Disorders

A news article found here describes and illustrates an annual religious ritual in Thailand that involves people choosing to have their cheeks pierced by objects large and small. Presenting this story in class should stimulate a lively discussion about how this relates to the body piercings that have become so prevalent in Western cultures in recent years, and whether either, neither, or both of these phenomena should be considered examples of psychological disorder—and why.